Skip to content

Ontario Court's perilous decision recognizes three Parents

Printer-friendly version

For Immediate Release from the CHRISTIAN LEGAL FELLOWSHIP (CLF)


January 3, 2007


In a unanimous judgment written by Justice Marc Rosenberg on behalf of Chief Justice Roy McMurtry and Justice Jean-Marc Labrosse, the Ontario Court of Appeal chose to exercise it's parens patriae jurisdiction to "fill a legislative gap" and extend a child's parentage to three individuals -- the biological mother and father as well as the mother's lesbian partner.  This court has now recognized a "three-parent family" and opened the way to introduce many legal variations of the family unit.


Ruth Ross, Executive Director of Christian Legal Fellowship, a member of the intervenor Alliance for Family & Marriage, states, "There remain outstanding questions as to whether a family comprised of three legal parents is in the best interests of the child. The full implications of this major, precedent-setting change have not been thoroughly examined.  Historically, policy decisions have been left to legislators who are charged with this responsibility."


This decision has international significance as it takes the lead into unstable territory most other countries have not ventured into -- redefining the family as we know it to include three parents.


While the court exercised its discretion in this case, other jurisdictions, such as France, chose to investigate thoroughly the social science data through its legislative arm, and found one mother and one father to be in the best interests of children. 


There is no doubt that this decision will cause a whole new vista of legal issues and many new court actions as it impacts parental rights and obligations particularly in marriage breakdowns or situations where one or more members of three parent families part company. Deciding what is in the best interests of the child in those circumstances will prove extremely complex, costly and potentially chaotic.


What will prevent this ruling from having similar application to heterosexual marriges upon breakdown and subsequent remarriage? Can one or two step-parents now apply for legal status as a parent and ultimately lead to four or even six parents being recognized by the courts as having say over the child's upbringing?  Will the third or fourth or fifth or sixth parent be afforded equal say?  What about the child?  What say will he/she have in terms of which parent or sets of parents they choose to live with?


The court asserted that present social conditions and attitudes have changed, however, a societal shift of this magnitude may not be as clear as the courts would have us believe. This judgment warrants action from provincial and federal governments to examine the social data and investigate the potential fallout for families to allow the broadest protection for children.


Click here to view background information and written legal arguments for The Alliance for Marriage and Family (comprised of Christian Legal Fellowship, Focus on the Family, Catholic Civil Rights League, REAL Women of Canada and Evangelical Fellowship of Canada).


Click here to view the decision of the Ontario Court of Appeal handed down on January 2, 2007.


For further information or to arrange an interview, please contact:


Elizabeth Davis, J.D.

Director of Communications


on behalf of


Ruth A.M. Ross, B.A., LL.B.
Executive Director

CHRISTIAN LEGAL FELLOWSHIP

l’Alliance des chrétiens en droit

Phone: (519) 641-8850  Fax:  (519) 641-8866
www.christianlegalfellowship.org

The Christian Legal Fellowship is a national not-for-profit association of legal professionals in Canada. The association, among other functions, explores the complex interrelationships between the practice and theory of law and Christian faith. The Fellowship has some 490 active members from several dozen Christian denominations working together to integrate Christian faith with law. 

Twitter

  • Do you use the PrayerMate app? You can follow the Christian Concern feed to receive daily prayer points about our c… https://t.co/v2tGiuhPSq 2 hours 56 min ago
  • In case you missed it: Evidence shows that no less than 108 universities in the United Kingdom have actively censor… https://t.co/QeK5VIlUSC 14 hours 16 min ago
  • Breaking News: Two street preachers questioned over hate speech have all charges dropped - https://t.co/8gwYDGC4Cn https://t.co/6txuQDBOg2 15 hours 29 min ago
  • In the news: Trump proclaims day of religious freedom for all — including nuns and bakers https://t.co/DG8CLtLHIU https://t.co/U2J3hWsWKv 16 hours 51 sec ago
  • Abort67 are in the Isle of Man campaigning for changes to the Abortion Law Reform Bill. If the bill is passed abort… https://t.co/Dy6TDPgc2U 17 hours 24 min ago

Subscribe to our emails